Cycling & Walking

Protected Bike Lanes in NYC: What DOT's Studies Actually Show

A plain-English look at NYC DOT's 2014, 2017 and 2021 bike lane studies: what they measured, what they found about injury risk and ridership, and their limits.

Key takeaways

  • NYC DOT's 2021 Safe Streets for Cycling study found protected bike lanes cut cyclist injury risk by 34% across 35 studied projects installed 2009–2018.
  • Conventional painted lanes in the same study showed a 32% risk reduction; DOT cautions the lane types are not directly comparable.
  • The 2017 Safer Cycling report found 89% of NYC cyclist deaths from 2006 to 2016 (where location was known) occurred on streets without a bike facility.
  • The 2014 Protected Bicycle Lanes in NYC report found injury crashes fell 17% on Manhattan avenues with at least three years of after data.
  • Studies describe average past results; they do not mean any particular lane is safe today.

Few street changes in New York draw as much debate as protected bike lanes. Rather than add another opinion, this article walks through what NYC DOT’s own published studies measured and found, in the order they were released, and flags the limits the agency itself attached to its numbers. If you are deciding how your family rides, read this alongside the current NYC Bike Map, because research describes the past, not today’s street conditions.

First, what counts as “protected”?

DOT’s 2021 study sorts on-street bike facilities into three classes:

DOT class Common name What it looks like
Class 1 Protected bike lane Physically separated from moving traffic, for example by a row of parked cars (a “parking-protected” lane)
Class 2 Conventional bike lane A lane marked with paint on the roadway, without physical separation
Class 3 Shared lane Markings in a travel lane that bikes share with other traffic

Off-street paths, such as greenways, are a separate category. State law also distinguishes a bicycle lane, a part of the roadway marked for bicycles (VTL §102-a), from a bicycle path, physically separated from motor traffic by open space or a barrier (VTL §102-b), as summarized in DOT’s bicycle rules guide.

2014: Protected Bicycle Lanes in NYC

DOT’s September 2014 report, Protected Bicycle Lanes in NYC, looked at Manhattan avenues where protected lanes had at least three years of “after” crash data: 12 projects on six avenues, about 7 miles in total, installed between 2007 and 2011. The report noted that DOT had installed more than 30 miles of protected lanes citywide since 2007.

Combining those corridors, DOT reported:

  • Crashes with injuries down 17 percent (514 before, 426 after)
  • Pedestrian injuries down 22 percent
  • Motor vehicle occupant injuries down 25 percent
  • Total injuries down 20 percent
  • Cyclist injuries roughly flat (100 before, 98 after), even as cycling on those streets increased sharply

That last point is why DOT also calculated a per-cyclist risk measure, dividing injuries by counted cyclist volumes. On the eight corridors it scored this way, risk fell on seven. The changes ranged widely: a 64.9 percent drop on 9th Avenue between 16th and 23rd streets, a 2.4 percent drop on 8th Avenue between 23rd and 34th, and an 11.2 percent increase on a short stretch of Broadway between 23rd and 18th. The report also tracked traffic: taxi speeds in the Manhattan core stayed roughly steady, and average travel times on 8th Avenue between 23rd and 34th improved 14 percent.

2017: Safer Cycling

The Safer Cycling report, produced jointly by DOT, the Health Department and NYPD, looked at the whole city rather than specific lanes. Key findings:

  • Ridership grew fast. DOT estimated about 164 million bike trips in 2015, up from nearly 66 million in 2006, an increase of 150 percent.
  • Risk per trip fell. Cyclist deaths averaged 12.8 per 100 million trips in 2011–2015, compared with 44.2 in 1996–2000, a 71 percent decline. Total deaths stayed relatively flat even as riding grew.
  • Most deaths happened away from bike lanes. Of the 199 cyclist deaths from 2006 to 2016, 89 percent of those with a known location occurred on streets with no bicycle facility.
  • Intersections dominate. 65 percent of cyclist deaths and 89 percent of deaths plus severe injuries happened at intersections.
  • Trucks are overrepresented. Trucks were involved in 27 percent of cyclist deaths, compared with 5 percent of serious injuries.

The report is careful about cause and effect. It says growth in cycling is a likely contributor to lower per-trip risk, a “safety in numbers” effect, and that the correlation suggests it may be happening in New York. It also identified ten Priority Bicycle Districts in Brooklyn and Queens with high injury numbers and few bike lanes.

2021: Safe Streets for Cycling

The October 2021 study, Safe Streets for Cycling, compares lane types in more detail than the earlier reports. It addressed a weakness of earlier work: simple before-and-after injury counts ignore the fact that more people start riding once a lane goes in.

What it measured. DOT screened for projects at least a quarter-mile long with weekday bike counts before and one year after installation. The sample had more than 100 projects installed from 2009 to 2018:

  • 35 protected lanes (31 miles)
  • 50 conventional lanes (46 miles)
  • 16 shared lanes (18 miles)

Risk was defined as cyclist injuries per mile divided by estimated cyclist volume, using up to three years of data before and after each project. Volumes were annualized with a model built from permanent counters on the Williamsburg, Pulaski and Queensboro bridges, Kent Avenue and Citi Bike usage, adjusted for weather and season.

What it found.

Facility type Change in cyclist risk
All lane types combined 32% lower
Protected lanes (Class 1) 34% lower; over 60% lower on the highest-risk streets
Conventional lanes (Class 2) 32% lower; 42% lower on low-volume streets
Shared lanes (Class 3) 18% lower

Both protected and conventional lanes were associated with bike volumes rising by more than 50 percent. Protected lanes showed their largest risk reduction, 35 percent, on one-way streets wider than 60 feet; conventional lanes reduced risk by 35 percent on one-way streets narrower than 40 feet. DOT’s press release on the study, issued October 20, 2021, summarized the takeaway as protected lanes for wider “spine” streets and conventional lanes for slower, narrower local streets.

Reading the numbers carefully

DOT attached its own caveats, and they matter:

  • Lane types are not head-to-head comparisons. Each design was chosen for a particular street. The study says a conventional lane should not be expected to perform the same way on the kinds of streets where protected lanes are used.
  • Results are evaluations, not predictions. The 2021 study describes its results as an evaluation of projects built from 2009 to 2018 under the design approach of the time, not a forecast for any new lane.
  • Averages hide variation. The 2014 corridor table shows one segment where risk rose. Individual blocks, intersections and mixing zones can differ from the corridor average.
  • Lower risk is not zero risk. The studies report changes in injury rates across groups of projects; they do not certify any particular lane or block as safe.

These studies come from the agency that builds the lanes. They describe their methods openly, which lets readers judge them, but independent research is a useful complement when you want a wider view.

What this means for a family deciding where to ride

DOT’s network statistics page listed 1,550 lane miles of bike network as of November 13, 2026, and says 99 percent of residents live within a mile of it. That does not mean every route is connected or protected end to end. The research points families toward a few habits:

  • Prefer protected lanes and off-street greenways where they exist, while recognizing they still cross intersections.
  • Pay the most attention at intersections and around trucks, where DOT’s 2017 data concentrated the most serious crashes.
  • Check today’s conditions, since construction and temporary changes are common.

Our guide to planning a bike route with the NYC Bike Map covers the official tools for that last step, and family cycling basics covers the rules for riding with children.

Sources

  1. Safe Streets for Cycling: How Street Design Affects Bicycle Safety and Ridership (October 2021) — NYC Department of Transportation (DOT), accessed November 13, 2026
  2. Safer Cycling: Bicycle Ridership and Safety in New York City (2017) — NYC DOT, NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene and NYPD, accessed November 13, 2026
  3. Protected Bicycle Lanes in NYC (September 2014) — NYC Department of Transportation (DOT), accessed November 13, 2026
  4. Press release: DOT study shows bike lanes improve safety (October 20, 2021) — NYC Department of Transportation (DOT), accessed November 13, 2026
  5. Bike Network and Ridership — NYC Department of Transportation (DOT), accessed November 13, 2026
  6. Safe Bicycling in New York City: Summary Listing of Bicycle Laws, Rules & Regulations (created March 31, 2026) — NYC Department of Transportation (DOT), accessed November 13, 2026

Rules, hours and programs change. Confirm details with the official source before you go. Spotted an error? Tell us.